logo
Ondalık oranlar (1.5)
Türkçe

From Champions League finish to drop zone: How Carrick's reign unravelled

Michael Carrick has been sacked as Manchester United head coach, months after guiding them back into the Champions League. One win in 10 Premier League games has left United in the relegation zone at the start of November.

Premier League · Manchester United

Michael Carrick

United salvaged a 4-4 draw against Aston Villa in Carrick's final game in charge. It was not enough to rescue a reign that had unravelled with remarkable speed, with former Tottenham and Chelsea boss Mauricio Pochettino set to take over.

Last season ended with a third-place finish and renewed optimism. This one brought United's worst start in 40 years, questions over recruitment and fitness, and public disagreements about how the team should play.

The calm before the collapse

Carrick's impact was immediate after taking over in January. Manchester City's visit to Old Trafford looked a difficult opening assignment, but a 2-0 win became the launchpad for an extraordinary turnaround.

“One of the best performances you'll see in any era by a United team,” was Gary Neville's assessment.

Gary Neville discussing Manchester United's performances
Neville praised Carrick's opening win over City; his assessment of United's players would become much harsher this season.

Wins over Arsenal, Fulham and Tottenham followed. United had won four successive Premier League matches for the first time in two years, and the mood was transformed.

Seventh when Carrick arrived, they finished third. Champions League qualification was secured with three games to spare, and his work earned him a nomination for the Premier League Manager of the Year award.

League wins after his January appointment
12 in 17 games
Points during that run
39

United collected more points during that period than even eventual champions Arsenal. Before Carrick's appointment, they had won only eight of their first 21 league games.

His most influential change was abandoning Ruben Amorim's preferred back three. That allowed Bruno Fernandes to move from the base of midfield, where he had looked a poor fit alongside Casemiro, into his favoured No 10 role.

Fernandes' open-play creativity rose by 81 per cent under Carrick. He broke the Premier League's single-season assists record and finished as both the PFA and FWA Player of the Year.

“Michael came in with a big personality but also with a lot of calmness about what he needed to do to bring the best out of the team.”

Bruno Fernandes, speaking in May

The player who flourished most under Carrick would also become central to the story of his downfall.

A summer that left the squad exposed

Carrick was appointed permanent head coach before United closed last season with a 3-0 victory at Brighton. But returning to Europe meant a minimum of eight additional games, ending the relatively light schedule he had enjoyed during his first months in charge.

Manchester United during their difficult start to the season

Three months later, the trio had yet to offer value for money. Meanwhile, the decision not to strengthen other areas had left familiar weaknesses exposed.

Player turnover in defence was minimal, and United continued to look short of quality there. Benjamin Sesko's injury problems left them without a proper No 9 for much of the season.

Preparation also came under scrutiny. Tielemans' revelation in August that fitness work had not been a focus during pre-season raised concerns, and sluggish performances subsequently brought further questions about the team's conditioning.

“The reality is they're not running enough, they're not showing enough tenacity, determination, fighting spirit. They're just not,” Neville said after United drew 1-1 with 10-man Tottenham, repeating criticism he had made after the draw with Fulham.

Carrick disputed that assessment, but tracking data placed United among the Premier League's bottom clubs for both distance covered and sprints. Opponents repeatedly found ways to overpower a side lacking intensity.

Results deteriorated. Frustration became public.

An opening-day defeat to Hull set the tone. Seven points from the first seven games amounted to United's worst start in 40 years.

Mauricio Pochettino, who is set to replace Michael Carrick
Pochettino is set to take over following Carrick's dismissal.

United's only league victory was a 5-2 home win over Ipswich. Until his penalty against Aston Villa on Sunday, it was also the only Premier League match this season in which Fernandes had scored or assisted. The loss of his influence was especially damaging.

Frustration was increasingly visible beyond the results. Following the Champions League defeat to Atletico Madrid, Lisandro Martinez publicly challenged the club's hierarchy and technical director Jason Wilcox over recruitment.

“We had a fantastic season last season, and now we expect more from the top, from upstairs, to bring in more players to compete because many teams have brought in many players as well.

“I expect more from our technical director. I have to be honest. And also, as a player, we have to do more. But it's also important to build a strong squad to be ready for this kind of night.”

Michael Carrick discussing Lisandro Martinez's comments

Martinez also appeared to question whether Carrick had adapted sufficiently. “He does his best,” he said. “But every season is different. You can't stay with what you did last season. The teams know how you play, they know every detail. If you don't change, next season is a big problem.”

Fernandes was more direct after the Champions League loss to Como, questioning the coaching staff's approach to pressing.

“It's a decision from the staff to not press man-to-man and sometimes leave a little space in behind and try to get the ball in the first moment, to wait for them, to give them the ball,” he said.

The pressing dispute

“But sometimes when you give the ball to these teams, they get confident, they have so many bodies behind the ball that make you run a lot, make people get frustrated, and when you recover the ball the legs and the brain are more difficult to make work.”

Bruno Fernandes

“We half pressed man-to-man in the second half and ended up conceding a goal from that. Whatever tactics you play, if you don't run back, you ain't going to win.”

Michael Carrick's response
Gary Neville discussing Bruno Fernandes's comments after the Como defeat
Neville believed Fernandes had “let himself down” with his comments after the Como game.

Carrick later insisted there was no divide between the players and coaching staff. Fernandes described reports of a strained relationship as “lies”. Even so, the prospect of Carrick's departure increasingly appeared a matter of timing.

Fernandes returned to the team after being left out of the 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth and scored his first Premier League goal since August in the draw with Villa. The player who had inspired United's revival last season could not do enough to save the coach who helped unlock it.